Argentine Malbec or Chilean Carmenere? The question that divides tables in Bogotá
In the world of Latin American wine, there are two varietals that have become emblems of their countries: Argentina’s Malbec and Chile’s Carmenere. Both are red, both are accessible, and both have passionate fans. Here, we help you understand the differences so you can choose the one that best fits your taste and occasion.
Argentine Malbec: power, fruit, and structure
Malbec originated in France, but it was in Mendoza, Argentina, that it found its promised land. The conditions of the Uco Valley and Luján de Cuyo—high altitude, stony soils, sunny days, and cold nights—produce Malbecs with a concentration of fruit and tannic structure that no other country can match.
Typical profile of Argentine Malbec:
- Color: deep red, intense violet
- Aromas: plum, blackberry, violets, chocolate, tobacco
- Palate: voluminous, firm yet polished tannins, long finish
- Ideal pairing: loin, ribs, barbecue (asado), aged cheeses
Merkato Malbecs to try: Clos de los Siete, Rutini Cabernet Malbec, Alta Vista Alto, Trumpeter Malbec.
Chilean Carmenere: smoothness, spice, and character
Carmenere was considered extinct in Europe until it was discovered that most Chilean vineyards had mistaken it for Merlot. Today, it is Chile's flagship grape, especially from the Colchagua Valley, and it produces wines with a unique profile: softer than Malbec, with herbal and spicy notes that make it immediately recognizable.
Typical profile of Chilean Carmenere:
- Color: ruby red with garnet reflections
- Aromas: mild green pepper, cherries, plums, spices
- Palate: medium-high body, soft tannins, fresh acidity, spicy finish
- Ideal pairing: grilled meats, pasta, roast chicken, semi-cured cheeses
Merkato Carmenere to try: Livana Carmenere, Tabaí Reserva Carmenere.
Which one to choose for the occasion?
| Occasion | Choose |
|---|---|
| Weekend barbecue | Malbec |
| Weekday dinner | Carmenere |
| As a gift | Premium Malbec |
| Everyday wine | Carmenere |
| Palates sensitive to tannins | Carmenere |
| Lovers of power | Malbec |
Our verdict
There is no absolute winner. But if you ask us which one to always have at home, we recommend having one of each: the Livana Carmenere for ordinary days and the Clos de los Siete or the Rutini for those that deserve something special.